中重度高血压患者舌下含服硝苯地平控释片降压的有效性和安全性:拜新同与欣然的对照研究

The effectiveness and safety of sublingual nifedipine controlled-release formulation in patients with moderate and severe hypertension:a comparasion study of Baixintong and Xinran

  • 摘要: 目的在血压明显增高的患者中证实舌下含服硝苯地平控释片30 mg的有效性和安全性,并比较两种制剂(拜新同和欣然)的差别。方法 2018年8月至2019年5月间纳入收缩压≥175或≥160 mm Hg伴有头痛的门诊高血压患者,分别进行安慰剂对照研究(采用单盲、随机对照的设计,以1∶1∶1分为拜新同、欣然或安慰剂3组,每组23例)和扩大样本量临床研究(从197例舌下含服硝苯地平控释片治疗的高血压患者中,以病例配对方法选取72例使用拜新同和72例使用欣然的患者)。使用同一电子血压计,重复测量含服后5、10、15和20 min的血压和脉率(代表心率)。计算各时点血压和心率的降低幅度和百分降幅(降低幅度/基线水平×100%)。两项试验的有效性指标为:治疗后20 min的收缩压或平均动脉压(MAP)降低幅度>10%;安全性指标:20 min时MAP百分降幅≤25%或收缩压≥140 mm Hg;同时伴有心率增加≤10次/min;或不出现心悸、头晕为安全。结果 (1)安慰剂对照研究:3组的年龄、性别、高血压用药情况、基线收缩压、舒张压、MAP和心率均具有可比性。含服5 min时两治疗组的收缩压即降低。在20 min时,拜新同组(159.6±9.6)比(182.0±4.7)mm Hg,P<0.05和欣然组(164.5±13.4)比(184.0±7.8)mm Hg,P<0.05收缩压较基线明显降低,而安慰剂组下降无统计学意义(177.7±12.2)比(182.7±9.4)mm Hg,P=0.154。3组MAP百分降幅平均值分别为7.3%、7.7%和1.7%,心率减少1~2次/min。(2)临床研究:144例患者的平均年龄为(65.6±11.4)岁(最大88岁)。拜新同组和欣然两组的性别构成、平均年龄、既往降压药使用以及服用钙通道阻滞剂的比例相似。含服20 min时两组收缩压百分降幅和MAP百分降幅相似。有5例患者在治疗过程中收缩压<140 mm Hg,收缩压为130 mm Hg者1例,其余4例收缩压>135 mm Hg。1例患者发生无症状的心率增加(从88.5升到104.0次/min)。有10例收缩压降低幅度<5 mm Hg;其中6例收缩压较基线轻度升高。结论对收缩压明显增高的高血压患者,舌下含服硝苯地平控释片30 mg能在20 min时有效而适度地降低收缩压和MAP,同时无不良反应发生。拜新同和欣然两种制剂的效果和安全性相似。

     

    Abstract: Objective To evaluate the effectiveness and safety of sublingual nifedipine controlled release of formulation(sub-Ni-f GITS) 30 mg in patients with moderate and severe hypertension. Methods Patients with systolic blood pressure(SBP)≥175 mm Hg, or SBP≥160 mm Hg and headache who visited outpatient department from August 2018 to May 2019 were included. Firstly, a randomized, placebo-controlled, single blind study was conducted, in which 69 patients were divided into 3 groups(n=23): control group(placebo), Baixintong(BXT) group(Ni-f preparation of Bayer company) and Xinran(XR) group(Ni-f preparation of Xiandai company). Then 144 patients were divided to BXT group(n=72) and XR group(n=72) to compare the safety and effectiveness of the preparations. Blood pressure(BP) and pulse rate(represent for heart rate, HR) were measured at the 5th, 10th, 15th, and 20th minutes after intervention. And BP and HR reductions(ΔBP and ΔHR) and reduction ratios were calculated. ΔBP or reduction of mean arterial pressure(ΔMAP)>10% at the 20th minute was defined as effective. ΔMAP≤25% or SBP≥140 mm Hg with ΔHR≤10 at the 20th minute, or no complain of palpitation and dizziness during the observation were defined as safe. Results In placebo-controlled study, age, gender, medical history of hypertension, baseline SBP, diastolic blood pressure(DBP), mean arterial pressure(MAP) and HR were comparable in 3 groups. SBP started to drop 5 minutes after intervention in BXT and XR group, and significantly decreased at the 20th minute (159.6±9.6) vs(182.0±4.7)mm Hg,(164.5±13.4) vs(184.0±7.8)mm Hg, both P<0.05, while did not significantly decrease in control group (177.7±12.2) vs(182.7±9.4)mm Hg, P=0.154. Reduction ratios of MAP were 7.3%, 7.7% and 1.7% respectively. HR did not significantly change after intervention in 3 groups. In case-control study, patients in both groups had comparable gender, mean age, medical history of hypertension, calcium channel blocker(CCB) useage and reduction ratios of SBP and MAP 20 minutes after sublingual nifedipine treatment. Five patients had SBP<140 mm Hg during the observation, with one SBP 130 and others >135 mm Hg. One patient’s HR increased from 88.5 to 104.0 beats/min. During observation, 10 patients had SBP reductions<5 mm Hg, 6 of whom had SBP slightly increased. Conclusions Sublingual 30 mg Ni-f GITS can effectively reduce SBP and MAP without adverse reactions for hypertensive patients with significantly increased SBP. Baixintong and Xinran had similar effectiveness and safety.

     

/

返回文章
返回